Exploring Within-Rater Category Ordering: A Simulation Study Using Adjacent-Categories Mokken Scale Analysis

摘要

The interpretation of ratings from educational performance assessments assumes that rating scale categories are ordered as expected (i.e., higher ratings correspond to higher levels of judged student achievement). However, this assumption must be verified empirically using measurement models that do not impose ordering constraints on the rating scale category thresholds, such as item response theory models based on adjacent-categories probabilities. This study considers the application of an adjacent-categories formulation of polytomous Mokken scale analysis (ac-MSA) models as a method for evaluating the degree to which rating scale categories are ordered as expected for individual raters in performance assessments. Using simulated data, this study builds on the preliminary application of ac-MSA models to rater-mediated performance assessments, in which a real data analysis suggested that these models can be used to identify disordered rating scale categories. The results suggested that ac-MSA models are sensitive to disordered categories within individual raters. Implications are discussed as they relate to research, theory, and practice for rater-mediated educational performance assessments.