《关于“定语＋人称代词”结构的思考》商榷三题

摘要

About the structure of attributive plus pronoun,scholars like Diao Yanbin,Wei Zhicheng,Wang Huayun,Zhang Fengqin and Feng Ming have divergent opinions.Those for the ＂synthetic theory＂ argue that though Chinese has such a structure the uses are very few in number.This article argues that this statement is not correct for there were a large number of uses of the attributive＋personal pronoun structure in Chinese before the May 4th Movement.So the structure of attributive＋personal pronoun is an inherent property of the Chinese language.%刁晏斌对＂定语＋人称代词＂的看法有一个深化过程,他后来支持汉语固有说,而魏志成是持＂日化＂说,汪化云、张凤琴、冯鸣持＂综合说＂。有些＂定语＋人称代词＂的＂定语＂非单一的＂体词性＂或＂谓词性＂,而是综合性的。持＂综合说＂的学者有一共同处,即承认汉语有＂定语＋人称代词＂现象,但数量很少,这不符合汉语事实,＂五四＂前的汉语中有大量的＂定语＋人称代词＂现象,因此,＂定语＋人称代词＂是汉语固有的语法现象。