首页> 外文期刊>Bioethics >The death of dignity is greatly exaggerated: Reflections 15 years after the declaration of dignity as a useless concept

【24h】

The death of dignity is greatly exaggerated: Reflections 15 years after the declaration of dignity as a useless concept

机译：尊严的死亡极大地夸大：尊严宣言后15年的思考作为无用的概念

获取原文

获取原文并翻译 | 示例

掌桥外文数据库（机构版） >>

开具论文收录证明 >>

文献代查 >>

页面导航

摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题

摘要

Abstract >Fifteen years ago, Ruth Macklin shook the medical community with her claim in the BMJ that dignity is a useless concept. Her essay provoked a storm of reactions. What have we learned from the debate? In this article I analyse the responses to her essay and the following debate to investigate whether she was right that “[d]ignity is a useless concept in medical ethics and can be eliminated without any loss of content.” While some of the commentaries misconstrued her claim and argue against strawmen, others forcefully maintained that the concept of dignity has functions beyond “respect for persons and their autonomy.” One important point that came out of the debate is that dignity is a generic concept that covers more ground than “respect for persons or their autonomy.” In particular, dignity seems to have a wide range of protective functions as well as having reciprocal, relational, and social aspects. Dignity appears more attributional and norm‐formative than respect for persons and autonomy. While the claim that dignity is unclear, vague, and can be used sloganistically seems highly relevant, it is argued that this vagueness fulfils important functions in ethics. Moreover, dismissing dignity because of its lack of clarity has implications for “respect for persons” and “autonomy,” which are also used vaguely and sloganistically. No doubt medical ethics should use as a clear concept as the context requires. Nonetheless, dignity still seems to be a widely used generic concept in ethical debates and doing as much ethical work as “respect for persons” or “respect for autonomy.” Therefore, the death of dignity seems to be greatly exaggerated. </abstract> </span> <span class="z_kbtn z_kbtnclass hoverxs" style="display: none;">展开▼</span> </div> <div class="translation abstracttxt"> <span class="zhankaihshouqi fivelineshidden" id="abstract"> <span>机译：</span><Abstract Type =“Main”XML：ID =“Bioe12752-Abs-Abs-0001”XML：Lang =“en”> <标题类型=“main”>抽象</ title> >十五年前，Ruth Macklin在BMJ中震惊了医学界，尊严是一种无用的概念。她的文章激起了反应的风暴。我们从辩论中学到了什么？在本文中，我分析了对她的论文和以下辩论的回答，以调查她是否正确的是“[D] Ingity是一种无用的理念，可以在没有任何内容的情况下消除。”虽然一些评论误解了她的索赔并反对草民，但其他人有力地坚持认为，尊严的概念已经超越“尊重人和自治”。出于辩论的一个重要观点是尊严是一种普遍的概念，涵盖比“尊重人或自主权”更多的理念。特别是，尊严似乎具有广泛的保护功能以及具有互惠的，关系和社会方面。尊严似乎比尊重人员和自主权更具归属和规范性。虽然尊严尚不清楚，模糊，并且可以使用口无主论似乎高度相关，但认为这种模糊性符合道德的重要功能。此外，由于其缺乏清晰度而对“尊重人”和“自治”的影响，驳回了尊严，这也是模糊和口道的“自治”。毫无疑问，随着上下文所需的，医疗道德应该用作明确的概念。尽管如此，尊严似乎仍然是道德辩论中广泛使用的通用概念，并尽可能多地作为“尊重人”或“尊重自主权”的良好工作。因此，尊严的死亡似乎大大夸大了。</ p> </摘要> </span> <span class="z_kbtn z_kbtnclass hoverxs" style="display: none;">展开▼</span> </div> </div> <div class="record"> <h2 class="all_title" id="enpatent33" >著录项</h2> <ul> <li> <span class="lefttit">来源</span> <div style="width: 86%;vertical-align: text-top;display: inline-block;"> <a href='/journal-foreign-14793/'>《Bioethics》</a> <b style="margin: 0 2px;">|</b><span>2020年第6期</span><b style="margin: 0 2px;">|</b><span>共10页</span> </div> </li> <li> <div class="author"> <span class="lefttit">作者</span> <p id="fAuthorthree" class="threelineshidden zhankaihshouqi"> </p> <span class="z_kbtnclass z_kbtnclassall hoverxs" id="zkzz" style="display: none;">展开▼</span> </div> </li> <li> <div style="display: flex;"> <span class="lefttit">作者单位</span> <div style="position: relative;margin-left: 3px;max-width: 639px;"> <div class="threelineshidden zhankaihshouqi" id="fOrgthree"> </div> <span class="z_kbtnclass z_kbtnclassall hoverxs" id="zhdw" style="display: none;">展开▼</span> </div> </div> </li> <li > <span class="lefttit">收录信息</span> <span style="width: 86%;vertical-align: text-top;display: inline-block;"></span> </li> <li> <span class="lefttit">原文格式</span> <span>PDF</span> </li> <li> <span class="lefttit">正文语种</span> <span>eng</span> </li> <li> <span class="lefttit">中图分类</span> <span><a href="https://www.zhangqiaokeyan.com/clc/15.html" title="生物科学">生物科学;</a></span> </li> <li class="antistop"> <span class="lefttit">关键词</span> <p style="width: 86%;vertical-align: text-top;"> <a style="color: #3E7FEB;" href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=autonomy&option=203" rel="nofollow">autonomy;</a> <a style="color: #3E7FEB;" href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=dignity&option=203" rel="nofollow">dignity;</a> </p> <div class="translation"> 机译：自主;尊严; </div> </li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="literature cardcommon"> <div class="similarity "> <h3 class="all_title" id="enpatent66">相似文献</h3> <div class="similaritytab clearfix"> <ul> <li class="active" >外文文献</li> <li >中文文献</li> </ul> </div> <div class="similarity_details"> <ul > <li> <div> <b>1. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/journal-foreign-detail/0704021837749.html">The death of dignity is greatly exaggerated: Reflections 15 years after the declaration of dignity as a useless concept</a> <b>[J]</b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> </a> <a href="/journal-foreign-14793/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor">Bioethics .</a> <span>2020</span><span>,第6期</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：尊严的死亡极大地夸大：尊严宣言后15年的思考作为无用的概念</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>2. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/journal-foreign-detail/0704014644530.html">Dignity: not such a useless concept</a> <b>[J]</b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Suzy Killmister&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Suzy Killmister </a> <a href="/journal-foreign-35026/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor">Journal of medical ethics .</a> <span>2010</span><span>,第3期</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：尊严：不是一个没用的概念</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>3. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-foreign_british-medical-journal_thesis/020415633648.html">Dignity is a useless concept</a> <b>[J]</b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Ruth Macklin&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Ruth Macklin </a> <a href="/journal-foreign-11220/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor">British Medical Journal .</a> <span>2003</span><span>,第7429期</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：尊严是没有用的概念</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>4. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-conference-foreign_meeting-200754_thesis/020513756155.html">Evolution of Virtual and Augmented Reality in Health: A Reflection from 15 Years of SVR</a> <b>[C]</b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Nunes Fatima L.S.&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Nunes Fatima L.S.,</a> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Machado Liliane S.&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Machado Liliane S.,</a> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Moraes Ronei M.&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Moraes Ronei M. </a> <a href="/conference-foreign-200754/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor">Symposium on Virtual and Augmented Reality .</a> <span>2014</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：健康虚拟现实和增强现实的演变：SVR 15年的反思</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>5. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-degree-foreign_mphd_thesis/02061235883.html">Autonomy, human dignity, and death with dignity: Advancing a relational view of human dignity in end-of-life bioethics.</a> <b>[D] </b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Belde, David M.&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Belde, David M. </a> <span>2005</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：自治，人类尊严和有尊严的死亡：在生命终结的生物伦理学中提出关于人类尊严的关系视图。</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>6. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-foreign-pmc_detail_thesis/04000467833.html">Whose dignity? Resolving ambiguities in the scope of human dignity in the Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights</a> <b>[O] </b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Harald Schmidt&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Harald Schmidt </a> <span>2007</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：谁的尊严？解决生物伦理与人权世界宣言中人的尊严范围内的歧义</span> </p> </li> <li> <div> <b>7. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/open-access_resources_thesis/0100036483571.html ">Whose dignity? Resolving ambiguities in the scope of “human dignity” in the Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights</a> <b>[O] </b> . <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=Schmidt, Harald&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">Schmidt, Harald </a> <span>2007</span> </span> </div> <p class="zwjiyix translation" style="max-width: initial;height: auto;word-break: break-all;white-space: initial;text-overflow: initial;overflow: initial;"> <span>机译：谁的尊严？解决《生物伦理与人权世界宣言》中“人的尊严”范围内的歧义</span> </p> </li> </ul> <ul style="display: none;"> <li> <div> <b>1. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-cn_chinese-medical-ethics_thesis/0201254037997.html">尊严死亡:现代社会亟需接纳的死亡理念——评王云岭《现代医学与尊严死亡》</a> <b>[J]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=张新庆&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 张新庆</a> <span> <a href="/journal-cn-6705/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 中国医学伦理学 </a> </span> <span> . 2017</span><span>,第012期</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>2. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-cn_journal-kunming-university-science-technology-social-edition_thesis/0201293438272.html">“尊严”概念于生命伦理学无用吗?</a> <b>[J]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=韩跃红&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 韩跃红</a> <span> <a href="/journal-cn-53332/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 昆明理工大学学报：社会科学版 </a> </span> <span> . 2012</span><span>,第6期</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>3. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-cn_chinese-medical-ethics_thesis/0201254002290.html">尊严死亡如何可能?——评王云岭《现代医学与尊严死亡》</a> <b>[J]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=陈化&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 陈化</a> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=刘俊荣&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">,刘俊荣</a> <span> <a href="/journal-cn-6705/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 中国医学伦理学 </a> </span> <span> . 2018</span><span>,第003期</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>4. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-cn_contemporary-marxism-review_thesis/0201266915839.html">作为“社会想象”的人类尊严——论1945年后人权与人类尊严宣言的历史意义</a> <b>[J]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=格奥格·劳曼&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 格奥格·劳曼</a> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=邹丽&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor">,邹丽</a> <span> <a href="/journal-cn-39804/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 当代国外马克思主义评论 </a> </span> <span> . 2012</span><span>,第001期</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>5. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-journal-cn_journal-chengdu-university-technology-social-sciences_thesis/0201223090730.html">“人的尊严”概念及其演变的研究综述--以康德尊严概念的研究综述为重点</a> <b>[J]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=刘睿&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 刘睿</a> <span> <a href="/journal-cn-1203/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 成都理工大学学报（社会科学版） </a> </span> <span> . 2015</span><span>,第002期</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>6. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-conference-cn_meeting-39014_thesis/020222439236.html">树立"四个自信",唤醒乡村教师职业尊严感——薄弱村小复兴之路的思考与探索</a> <b>[C]</b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=李冬梅&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 李冬梅</a> <span> <a href="/conference-cn-39014/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_authcolor"> . 第二届全国乡村班主任发展研究论坛 </a> <span> <span> . 2018</span> </span> </div> </li> <li> <div> <b>7. </b><a class="enjiyixqcontent" href="/academic-degree-domestic_mphd_thesis/020313179890.html">人，尊严地生存——“人的尊严”的法理学思考</a> <b>[A] </b> <span> <a href="/search.html?doctypes=4_5_6_1-0_4-0_1_2_3_7_9&sertext=方宁&option=202" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" class="tuijian_auth tuijian_authcolor"> . 方宁</a> <span> . 2004</span> </span> </div> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="theme cardcommon" style="overflow: auto;display:none"> <h3 class="all_title" id="enpatent55">相关主题</h3> <ul id="subject"> </ul> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="right rightcon"> <div class="details_img cardcommon clearfix" style="margin-bottom: 10px;display:none;" > </div> </div> </div> <div id="thesis_get_original1" class="downloadBth" style="bottom: 19px;z-index: 999;" onclick="ywcd('0704021837749','4',7,2,1,'',this,24)" class="delivery" prompt="010401" title="通过人工服务将文献原文发送至邮箱" >获取原文</div> <div class="journalsub-pop-up" style="display: none"> <div class="journal-sub"> <h2>期刊订阅</h2> <img src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/img/loginclose.png" alt="" onclick="$('.journalsub-pop-up').hide()"> <p class="pardon">抱歉，该期刊暂不可订阅，敬请期待！</p> <p class="current">目前支持订阅全部北京大学中文核心（2020）期刊目录。</p> <div style="display: flex;margin-top: 69px;justify-content: space-between;"> <div class="no-sub" onclick="$('.journalsub-pop-up').hide()">暂不订阅</div> <div class="other-sub" onclick="continueSub('from=pc-detail')">继续订阅其他期刊</div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="right_btn"> <ul> <li class="gouwuche">  </li> <li class="yijian"> <a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="link_analysis('/mycenter/auth/complaint.html',this)">意见反馈</a> </li> <li class="top"> <a href="javascript:scrollTo(0,0);">回到顶部</a> </li> <li class="shouye"> <a href="/">回到首页</a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="xllindexfooter"> <div class="xllindexfootercenter"> <div class="xllindexfooterleft left" > <div class="xllindexfooterleftli"> <ul> <li><a href="/about.html">关于掌桥</a></li> <li><a href="/help/helpmap.html">资源导航</a></li> <li><a href="/help/helpguide.html">新手指南</a></li> <li><a href="/help/helpcenter.html">常见问题</a></li> <li><a href="/sitemap.html">网站地图</a></li> <li><a href="/help/helpcenter.html?type=9">版权声明</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="xllindexfooterleft"> <p class="xllindexfooterlefteamil">客服邮箱：kefu@zhangqiaokeyan.com</p> <div class="xllindexfooterlefttcp"> <div class="xllindexfooterpoliceiimg"></div> <div class="xllindexfooterpoliceispan"> <span>京公网安备：11010802029741号 </span> <span>ICP备案号：<a href="https://beian.miit.gov.cn" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">京ICP备15016152号-6</a></span> <span>六维联合信息科技 (北京) 有限公司©版权所有</span> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="xllindexfooterright left"> <ul> <li> <p style="font-weight: bold;">客服微信</p> <div></div> </li> <li> <p style="font-weight: bold;">服务号</p> <div></div> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <span id="0704021837749down" data-source="7," data-out-id="f+sSrMa6PHL7SAFCEJr/16XKdnRsmbRy8G1dVhTNT7FlPAgIBdyNi0DpHpDhj85j," data-f-source-id="7" data-title="The death of dignity is greatly exaggerated: Reflections 15 years after the declaration of dignity as a useless concept" data-price="20" data-site-name="" data-transnum="24" style="display:none;"></span> <input type="hidden" value="4" id="sourcetype"> <input type="hidden" value="14793" id="journalid"> <input type="hidden" value="1" id="inyn_provide_service_level"> <input type="hidden" value="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com" id="imgcdn"> <input type="hidden" value="1" id="isdeatail"> <input type="hidden" value="" id="syyn_indexed_database"> <input type="hidden" value="" id="servicetype"> <input type="hidden" id="pagename" value="The death of dignity is greatly exaggerated: Reflections 15 years after the declaration of dignity as a useless concept"/> <input type="hidden" value="thesis_get_original" id="pageIdentification"> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/jquery-1.12.4.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/lwlh_ajax.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/zq.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/common.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/jquery.cookie.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/top.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/tip.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/login.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/down.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/search.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/searchtype.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/user/regist.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/zxs_solor/detail.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://www.zhangqiaokeyan.com/statistics/static/pagecollection.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/tj.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/pushbaidu.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/common/history.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/util/cookie.js?v=5.7.7"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.zhangqiaokeyan.com/js/weipu/weipu.js?v=5.7.7"></script> </body> <script> $(function(){ var weiPuStatus = getCookie('WeiPuStatus'); if(weiPuStatus){ tipWeiPuStatus(weiPuStatus); delCookie('WeiPuStatus'); } getFacetKeywordVoInId(); var sourcetype = $("#sourcetype").val(); var inyn_provide_service_level = $("#inyn_provide_service_level").val(); if((sourcetype ==1||sourcetype==4)&&inyn_provide_service_level!=4){ getJournal(); } }) </script> </html>