The need to consider searcher efficiency and carcass persistence in railway wildlife fatality studies

摘要

To improve mitigation planning on railways, it is crucial to accurately assess the number of fatalities resulting from this type of infrastructure. To illustrate the relevance of considering the two main errors from the sampling process (searcher efficiency and carcass persistence), we corrected the estimation of mammal fatalities (> 1 kg) on a 750-km railway located in the Brazilian Savanna accounting for these errors. Observed fatalities were collected by two observers in a rail inspection vehicle (RV). We estimated searcher efficiency comparing the number of carcasses found during the searcher efficiency trials on foot and by RV on the same subsections of the railway. Carcass persistence was estimated based on trials with a subset of carcasses that had their persistence verified over three consecutive days. Searcher efficiency was 29.8% and daily carcass persistence probability was 99.7%. Nine surveys on the entire railway (2015-2016) recorded 1950 carcasses and, after correcting for the sampling errors, we estimated that 4286 mammals died on this railway in 23 months. This estimate is 2.2 times larger than the observed number of fatalities. These errors should not be neglected, as our results demonstrate that the number of observed carcasses is a misperception in relation to the true number of fatalities caused by the railway. However, our results also indicate that dealing with these errors in railway ecology is still a challenge. We stress the need to test more suitable sampling designs for fatality estimates on railways.