A Revisit of Hashing Algorithms for Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search

摘要

Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search (ANNS) is a fundamental problem in many areas of machine learning and data mining. During the past decade, numerous hashing algorithms are proposed to solve this problem. Every proposed algorithm claims to outperform Locality Sensitive Hashing (LSH), which is the most popular hashing method. However, the evaluation of these hashing article was not thorough enough, and the claim should be re-examined. If implemented correctly, almost all the hashing methods will have their performance improved as the code length increases. However, many existing hashing article only report the performance with the code length shorter than 128. In this article, we carefully revisit the problem of search-with-a-hash-index and analyze the pros and cons of two popular hash index search procedures. Then we proposed a simple but effective novel hash index search approach and made a thorough comparison of eleven popular hashing algorithms. Surprisingly, the random-projection-based Locality Sensitive Hashing ranked the first, which is in contradiction to the claims in all the other 10 hashing article. Despite the extreme simplicity of random-projection-based LSH, our results show that the capability of this algorithm has been far underestimated. For the sake of reproducibility, all the codes used in the article are released on GitHub, which can be used as a testing platform for a fair comparison between various hashing algorithms.