Corrective Enforcement: A New Paradigm of Security Policy Enforcement by Monitors

摘要

Runtime monitoring is an increasingly popular method to ensure the safe execution of untrusted codes. Monitors observe and transform the execution of these codes, responding when needed to correct or prevent a violation of a user-defined security policy. Prior research has shown that the set of properties monitors can enforce correlates with the latitude they are given to transform and alter the target execution. But for enforcement to be meaningful this capacity must be constrained, otherwise the monitor can enforce any property, but not necessarily in a manner that is useful or desirable. However, such constraints have not been significantly addressed in prior work. In this article, we develop a new paradigm of security policy enforcement in which the behavior of the enforcement mechanism is restricted to ensure that valid aspects present in the execution are preserved notwithstanding any transformation it may perform. These restrictions capture the desired behavior of valid executions of the program, and are stated by way of a preorder over sequences. The resulting model is closer than previous ones to what would be expected of a real-life monitor, from which we demand a minimal footprint on both valid and invalid executions. We illustrate this framework with examples of real-life security properties. Since several different enforcement alternatives of the same property are made possible by the flexibility of this type of enforcement, our study also provides metrics that allow the user to compare monitors objectively and choose the best enforcement paradigm for a given situation.