Shear Bond Strength and ARI Score of Chemically Cured Orthodontic Adhesive Resins

摘要

The purpose of this study was to compare shear bond strength and to evaluate Adhesive Remnant Index (ARI) score among three chemically cured orthodontic adhesive resins, namely Unite (3M Unitek, USA), Rely-a-Bond (Reliance, USA) and Ortho-Force (China). Materials and methods: Ninety extracted human maxillary premolars were randomly divided into 3 groups (30 teeth/group). Upper premolar metal brackets (Ormco, USA) were boned by using the following adhesive systems: Unite, Rely-a-Bond and Ortho-Force. After 24 hours, shear bond strength was tested by using a Universal Testing Machine with a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min. After debonding, all teeth and brackets were examined under 10-times magnification and scored by using Image-Pro Plus 7.0 software program. Results: One-way ANOVA followed by post-hoc Tukey HSD multiple comparison test showed a statistically significant (P<0.05) difference among groups. Ortho-Force had the lowest shear bond strength (17.53±3.60 MPa) and demonstrated statistically significant difference (P<0.05) from the other groups. The difference between Unite (22.40±3.11 MPa) and Rely-a-Bond (20.67±2.70 MPa) was not statistically significant. The bond failure sites were categorized according to the ARI, and the Chi-square test showed significant differences in the ARI scores (P<0.05) among all sample groups. The ARI score of 3 was found to be the most prevalent in Ortho-force (73.33%), followed by Unite (66.67%), and Rely-a-Bond (0%). In Rely-a-Bond group, ARI score of 1 was the most prevalent (66.67%). Only Unite had no residual adhesive left on tooth surface after debonding (6.67%). Conclusions: Unite and Rely-a-Bond produced greater shear bond strength than Ortho-Force. According to ARI score, Unite and Ortho-Force had a high frequency of all the adhesive remained on the tooth surface but Rely-a-Bond had high frequency of less than half the adhesive remained on the tooth surface.