Parent Assignment Is Hard for the MDL, AIC, and NML Costs

摘要

Several hardness results are presented for the parent assignment problem: Given m observations of n attributes x_1,..., x_n, find the best parents for x_n, that is, a subset of the preceding attributes so as to minimize a fixed cost function. This attribute or feature selection task plays an important role, e.g., in structure learning in Bayesian networks, yet little is known about its computational complexity. In this paper we prove that, under the commonly adopted full-multinomial likelihood model, the MDL, BIC, or AIC cost cannot be approximated in polynomial time to a ratio less than 2 unless there exists a polynomial-time algorithm for determining whether a directed graph with n nodes has a dominating set of size log n, a LOGSNP-complete problem for which no polynomial-time algorithm is known; as we also show, it is unlikely that these penalized maximum likelihood costs can be approximated to within any constant ratio. For the NML (normalized maximum likelihood) cost we prove an NP-completeness result. These results both justify the application of existing methods and motivate research on heuristic and super-polynomial-time algorithms.