ON THE FEASIBILITY OF NUCLEAR VERSUS COMBUSTION GAS TURBINE PROPULSION FOR HIGH-SPEED CARGO SHIPS

摘要

This paper presents the outcome of a study on the feasibility of a nuclear powered High-Speed Pentamaran, initiated by Nigel Gee and Associates and the Delft University of Technology. It explores the competitiveness of a nuclear power plant for the critical characteristics of a marine propulsion plant. Three nuclear reactor types are selected: the Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR), the Pebble-bed and Prismatic-block HTGR. Their characteristics are estimated for a power range from 100 MWth to 1000 MWth in a parametric design, providing a level base for comparison with conventional gas turbine technology. The reactor scaling is based on reference reactors with an emphasis on marine application. This implies that preference is given to passive safely and simplicity, as they are key-factors for a marine power plant. A case study for a 60-knot Pentamaran shows the impact of a nuclear power plant on a ship designed with combustion gas turbine propulsion. The Prismatic-block HTGR is chosen as most suitable because of its low weight compared to the PWR, in spite of the proven technology of a PWR. The Pebble-bed HTGR is considered too voluminous for High-Speed craft. Conservative data and priority to simple systems and high safety leads to an unfavorable high weight of the nuclear plant in competition with the original gas turbine driven Pentamaran. The nuclear powered ship has some clear advantages at high sailing ranges.