A Monte Carlo comparison of studentized bootstrap and permutation tests for heteroscedastic two-sample problems

摘要

The present Monte Carlo study compares bootstrap and permutation tests for semiparametric heteroscedastic two-sample testing problems of Behrens-Fisher type. The underlying functionals to be tested are (a) the difference of the means and (b) the Wilcoxon functional P(Y < X) which is invariant under strictly increasing transformations. The consideration leads to semi-parametric modifications of Welch type tests for the Behrens-Fisher model and an extended two-sample Wilcoxon test which also works under some null hypothesis with non-exchangeable distributions. The present Monte Carlo study confirms the high quality of studentized permutation tests at finite sample size. They are typically better than tests with asymptotic critical values and for many situations and they are also better than two-sample. bootstrap tests when their type I error probabilities are compared.