Clinical accuracy of cervicothoracic pedicle screw placement: a comparison of the 'open' lamino-foraminotomy and computer-assisted techniques.

摘要

OBJECTIVE: Posterior transpedicular fixation at the cervicothoracic junction (CTJ) is increasing in popularity. However, the clinical accuracy of pedicle screw placement at the CTJ has not been specifically assessed. METHODS: Between January 2000 and July 2004, 60 consecutive patients underwent a variety of posterior spinal procedures necessitating pedicle screw placement at C7, T1, and T2. Thirty-two patients had cervicothoracic screws (3.5 to 4.5 mm) placed by an "open" technique (laminectomies or lamino-foraminotomies) and 28 patients with either a closed (before any decompression) 2-dimensional (n=19, fluoroscopy) or 3-dimensional (n=9, CT) computer-assisted technique. Screws were independently assessed for pedicle breach on postoperative CT and scored using a points-based classification system. RESULTS: The total number of screws placed was 86, 63 and 45 in the open, closed-2-dimensional and closed-3-dimensional groups, respectively. Overall, 61(70.9%), 51(81%), and 40(89%) screws were completely within the pedicle. In the open group, the majority of pedicle breaches were more than 2 mm [n=3 (<2 mm), n=20 (2-4 mm), n=2 (>4 mm)]. Screw violation occurred laterally 11/25(44%), medially 3/25(12%), inferiorly 7/25(28%), and superiorly 4/25(16%). In the closed technique, all breaches were lateral. Seventeen screws (n=11-2-dimensional, n=5-3-dimensional) breached the pedicle by a margin of less than 2 mm and 1 screw (2-dimensional) by 2 to 4 mm. Pedicle screw accuracy was significantly improved with computer-assisted techniques. However, there was no significant difference between the 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional techniques. For all patients, there were no clinically significant screw misplacements, nor any need for screw revision. CONCLUSIONS: Computer-assisted surgery allows for more accurate placement of pedicle screws at the CTJ. Although a higher proportion of major pedicular breaches occurred in the "open lamina/lamino-foraminotomy" group, no screws required revision in either group.