A new in vivo method for testing closures of gastric NOTES incisions using leak of the closure or gastric yield as endpoints

摘要

Background: We developed a non-survival in vivo model for testing of gastric natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) closures based on the gastric yield pressure. The aim of this study was to test our model comparing different endoscopic closure techniques with surgical closure of a NOTES gastric incision. Methods: Laparotomy was performed in 30 pigs. One tube for air inflation and one manometry tube were inserted into the stomach via the pylorus, which was closed gas-tight, and the abdominal wall was closed. The stomach was inflated with air, and the gastroesophageal yield pressure was measured. A gastroscopy was performed, and a standard NOTES access was created followed by randomization to closure by surgical suturing, T-tags, Padlock-G over-the-scope (OTS)-clips, OVESCO OTS-clips, and traditional clips. All closures were tested twice with air insufflation. Gastric yield pressure or leak pressure of each closure was recorded. Results: The mean baseline gastric yield pressure was 80.5 mm Hg. Post-closure yield pressure was 79.9 mm Hg. Leak test results after closure were as follows: surgery, 0/6 leaked; T-tags, 1/6 leaked before reaching yield pressure (56 mm Hg); Padlock-G, 2/5 leaked (71.5 mm Hg); OVESCO OTS-clips, 3/6 leaked (27.2 mm Hg); and traditional clips, 5/6 leaked (27.2 mm Hg). TAS T-tags and surgical closures leaked significantly less than the other groups (P=.01). Traditional clips and OVESCO OTS-clips leaked at significantly lower pressures than the other three groups (P=.007). Conclusion: This in vivo model using leak of the closure or the gastric yield pressure as endpoints for testing of the closure strength of a NOTES gastric access site seems to be reproducible. Our results support closure with T-tags and Padlock-G-clips over OVESCO OTS-clips and standard endoscopic clips.