Non-equilibrium processes in ash-laden volcanic plumes: new insights from 3D multiphase flow simulations

摘要

In the framework of the IAVCEI (International Association of Volcanology and Chemistry of the Earth Interior) initiative on volcanic plume models intercomparison, we discuss three-dimensional numerical simulations performed with the multiphase flow model PDAC (Pyroclastic Dispersal Analysis Code). The model describes the dynamics of volcanic and atmospheric gases (in absence of wind) and two pyroclastic phases by adopting a non-equilibrium Eulerian-Eulerian formulation. Accordingly, gas and particulate phases are treated as interpenetrating fluids, interacting with each other through momentum (drag) and heat exchange. Numerical results describe the time-wise and spatial evolution of weak (mass eruption rate: 1.5 x 10(6) kg/s) and strong (mass eruption rate: 1.5 x 10(6) kg/s) plumes. The two tested cases display a remarkably different phenomenology, associated with the different roles of atmospheric stratification, compressibility and mechanism of buoyancy reversal, reflecting in a different structure of the plume, of the turbulent eddies and of the atmospheric circulation. This also brings about different rates of turbulent mixing and atmospheric air entrainment. The adopted multiphase flow model allows to quantify temperature and velocity differences between the gas and particles, including settling, preferential concentration by turbulence and thermal non-equilibrium, as a function of their Stokes number, i.e., the ratio between their kinetic equilibrium time and the characteristic large-eddy turnover time of the turbulent plume. As a result, the spatial and temporal distribution of coarse ash in the atmosphere significantly differs from that of the fine ash, leading to a modification of the plume shape. Finally, three-dimensional numerical results have been averaged in time and across horizontal slices in order to obtain a one-dimensional picture of the plume in a stationary regime. For the weak plume, the results are consistent with one-dimensional models, at least in the buoyant plume region, and allow to reckon a variable, effective entrainment coefficient with a mean value around 0.1 (consistently with laboratory experiments). For the strong plume, analysis of the results reveals that the two most critical assumptions of one-dimensional integral models are the self-similarity and the pressure equilibrium. In such a case, the plume appears to be controlled by the dynamics in the jet stage (below the buoyancy reversal) and by mesoscale voracity associated with the development of the umbrella. (C) 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.