作为同文同种的中国大陆和台湾地区人文社科学术期刊，发展历程和取得的成就有很多相似之处。通过对两岸高校人文社科学术期刊关于综合性期刊的定位、具体的编审体系运作机制、引文索引评价体系、开放性和国际化进展等方面的比较，可以发现虽然台湾地区的人文社科期刊在主办方式、编辑出版、栏目设置、评价体系等方面与大陆极其相似，但是在高校学术期刊的定位上还是有很大的不同。尤其是当前大陆对综合性大学学报的改革，一直在酝酿和讨论中起起落落。到目前为止，并没有更加明确的关于综合性大学学报改革的新思路出台，但是专业化发展一直是教育部和国家新闻出版广电总局对综合性大学学报未来发展的期许所在。这方面台湾地区的发展经验或可借鉴，把综合性大学学报的发展方向，定位在向单学科和局部多学科学报的转型上，这样比单纯的市场化改革或者集体转型为专业期刊效果更好。另外，在编审体系运作机制方面，台湾地区更注重发挥编委会的作用、对退稿率和用稿程序都更加明确；相对来说，台湾地区也普遍重视学术期刊的开放性和国际化推广，尤其在培养青年学生方面发挥了重要作用。%As the same language, the development course and achievements of humanities and social science academic journals in China mainland and Taiwan have much in common. Through the comparison of the positioning of the comprehensive journals, specific editorial system operation mechanism, citation index evaluation system and openness and internationalization progress of the humanities and social science academic journals in China mainland and Taiwan, it can be found that although Taiwan's humanities and social science journals are so similar to those of the mainland in terms of sponsoring way, editing and publishing, column setting, and evaluation system, the positioning of academic journals of universities is very different. Especially the current reform of comprehensive university journal is rise and fall under discussion all the time. So far, there is no more clear new way of thinking about the comprehensive university journal reform. But professional development has been the expectations of the Ministry of Education and the State General Administration of Press and Publication, Radio and Television for future development of comprehensive university journal. In this aspect, Taiwan's development experience or lessons can be taken as a reference. If the development direction of comprehensive university journal is positioned towards the transformation of single discipline and local multidisciplinary, the effect will be much better compared with the purely market-oriented reform or collective transformation of professional journals. In addition, in the aspect of editing system operation mechanism, Taiwan pays more attention to the role of the editorial board, the rejection rate and adoption procedures are clearer. Relatively speaking, Taiwan emphasizes popularly on academic journals’ openness and internationalization, especially it plays an important role in cultivating young students.
展开▼
