Duration of electroencephalographic recordings in patients with epilepsy

摘要

Purpose: Previous studies have demonstrated different diagnostic yields with electroencephalography (EEG). Due to the small sample sizes or different patient populations (outpatients or inpatients only) in these previous studies, the clinical use of routine EEG and outpatient/inpatient video-EEG monitoring (VEM) needs further clarification. In this study, we investigated EEGs obtained from patients referred by epileptologists; by comparing the results of different EEG methods, we sought to determine the optimal durations and specific types of EEG recordings for different clinical situations. Methods: The data from 335 routine EEGs, 281 3 h outpatient VEMs, and 247 inpatient VEMs (>48 h) were reviewed. We analyzed the latency to the first epileptiform discharge or clinical event. Results: In patients undergoing outpatient VEMs, 48% of the first epileptiform discharges appeared within 20 min, and 64% appeared within 30 min. In patients undergoing inpatient VEMs, 21.2% had their first attack within 3 h. The second peak of event occurrence was during the 33rd-36th h. Only 3.5% of the seizures were recorded after 57 h. The detection rate of epileptiform discharges was higher for 3 h outpatient VEM than for routine EEG (54.1% versus 16.4%, p < 0.01). Epileptic and/or nonepileptic events were recorded in 45.8% of the inpatient VEMs, the diagnostic yield of which was higher than for outpatient VEMs (p < 0.01). Since the patients in this study had been selected to limit the bias between each group, the diagnostic yield of EEGs in this study are likely to have been higher than those found in routine practice. Patients with generalized epilepsy had a shorter latency to the first epileptiform discharge compared to patients with localization-related epilepsy (mean, 22.1 min versus 33.9 min, p < 0.05). Conclusions: Two-thirds of epileptiform discharges were detected within 30 min of VEM. A 30-min recording is recommended for routine EEG examinations that aim to detect epileptiform discharges. A 3 h outpatient VEM is a reasonable option when a routine EEG fails to detect epileptiform discharges. The latency to the first epileptiform discharge was shorter in patients with generalized epilepsy than in patients with localization-related epilepsy. 48 h of inpatient VEM might be adequate for detecting the target events.