Offshore refuges support higher densities and show slower population declines of wintering Ruddy TurnstonesArenaria interpres: a response

摘要

In this reply, we confirm that the results of the original paper are robust and that our conclusions were correct: densities of Ruddy TurnstonesArenaria interpreswere lower on sites located further from undisturbed refuges. There are two points of learning here: (i) taking the findings of a paper based purely on what is published is normal but there is an unpublished iterative process for analysis that is often hidden from a reader (described here), so we refute that our results were caused by chance; (ii) we published a result based on an incorrect method in the revision process. We hope that other researchers involved in long-term projects involving large and complex datasets can learn from our mistake, as we will endeavour to do.