Exploring the Role of Decoherence in Condensed-Phase Nonadiabatic Dynamics:A Comparison of Different Mixed Quantum/Classical Simulation Algorithms for the Excited Hydrated Electron

摘要

Mixed quantum/classical(MQC)molecular dynamics simulation has become the method of choice for simulating the dynamics of quantum mechanical objects that interact with condensed-phase systems.There are many MQC algorithms available,however,and in cases where nonadiabatic coupling is important,different algorithms may lead to different results.Thus,it has been difficult to reach definitive conclusions about relaxation dynamics using nonadiabatic MQC methods because one is never certain whether any given algorithm includes enough of the necessary physics.In this paper,we explore the physics underlying different nonadiabatic MQC algorithms by comparing and contrasting the excited-state relaxation dynamics of the prototypical condensed-phase MQC system,the hydrated electron,calculated using different algorithms,including:fewest-switches surface hopping,stationary-phase surface hopping,and mean-field dynamics with surface hopping.We also describe in detail how a new nonadiabatic algorithm,mean-field dynamics with stochastic decoherence(MF-SD),is to be implemented for condensed-phase problems,and we apply MF-SD to the excited-state relaxation of the hydrated electron.Our discussion emphasizes the different ways quantum decoherence is treated in each algorithm and the resulting implications for hydrated-electron relaxation dynamics.We find that for three MQC methods that use Tully's fewest-switches criterion to determine surface hopping probabilities,the excited-state lifetime of the electron is the same.Moreover,the nonequilibrium solvent response function of the excited hydrated electron is the same with all of the nonadiabatic MQC algorithms discussed here,so that all of the algorithms would produce similar agreement with experiment.Despite the identical solvent response predicted by each MQC algorithm,we find that MF-SD allows much more mixing of multiple basis states into the quantum wave function than do other methods.This leads to an excited-state lifetime that is longer with MF-SD than with any method that incorporates nonadiabatic effects with the fewest-switches surface hopping criterion.