Emotion without a word: Shame and guilt among Raramuri Indians and rural Javanese

摘要

The Rardmuri Indians in Mexico use 1 word for guilt and shame. In this article, the authors show that the Rardmuri nevertheless differentiate between shame and guilt characteristics, similar to cultural populations that use 2 words for these emotions. Emotion-eliciting situations were collected among the Rardmuri and among rural Javanese and were rated on shame and guilt by Dutch and Indonesian students. These ratings were used to select 18 shame-eliciting and guilt-eliciting situations as stimuli. The Rardmuri (N = 229) and the Javanese (N = 213) rated the situations on 29 emotion characteristics that previously had been found to differentiate shame from guilt in an international student sample. For most characteristics, a pattern of differentiation sirmlar to that found among the students was found for both the Javanese and the Rardmuri.