参事会議事録と作品集に見るスイス·チューリッヒ市建築賞の基本理念·審査方針·評価基準の変遷と特徴: チューリッヒ市による建築評価の理念と手法に関する研究 その2

摘要

本稿は、本賞が設計者ではなく施主(Bauherr)を表彰の主対象とすることを踏まえた上で、審査方針並びに評価基準に関わる4つのキーワート(Baugesinnung, staedtebaulich, Stadtbild, Verstaendnis)を通して議事録の詳細を追うことで、65余年にわたる本賞の基本理念、審查方針、評価基準の変遷と特徴を明らかにした。%Auszeichnung fuer gute Bauten der Stadt Zuerich is an architectural prize first established by the Zurich municipal authority together with local architects in 1945. The intent of this paper is to clarify the transition and feature of the philosophy, evaluation policy and criterion of the prize by analyzing the minutes and statements of the City of Zurich. The conclusions in this study are as follows; Evaluating clients' and architects' conviction about buildings is the most significant philosophy of the prize through more than sixty-five years. Archiving and releasing the minutes as official records makes it possible to follow the initial philosophy. The evaluation policies of all the past sixteen juries have been set based on the trend of the society in each period. To evaluate architectural works in the light of the urban context is an unquestioned criterion through all the past sixteen juries.