If I only had a brain: Yip Harburg, J. Edgar Hoover, and the failures of FBI intelligence work

摘要

E. Y. Harburg, the lyricist behind The Wizard of Oz, remains one of the most important songwriters blacklisted during the Cold War. His removal from Hollywood features in the 1950s denied moviegoers a distinct American voice whose lyrics mixed humor and entertainment to champion liberal causes. From 1944-1972, Director J. Edgar Hoover and the Bureau's major field offices investigated Harburg. His declassified FBI file shows institutionalized incompetence in the way the Bureau went about writing reports, evaluating evidence, making conclusions, and conducting counter-intelligence work. Harburg's story illuminates the battle between the left and right to shape popular culture during the Cold War. Hoover and Harburg held opposing views on politics, religion, economics, and race. Yet both men shared a fervent faith in popular culture's capacity to transform America. Together they vied to remake the nation according to their own distinct visions - Hoover's fear of declension stood in contrast to Harburg's hope for radical progress.