Radiologists’ Performance at Reduced Recall Rates in Mammography: A Laboratory Study

摘要

Rationale and objectives: Target recall rates are often used as a performance indicator in mammography screeningprograms with the intention of reducing false positive decisions, over diagnosis and anxiety for participants. However,the relationship between target recall rates and cancer detection is unclear, especially when readers are directed toadhere to a predetermined rate. The purpose of this study was to explore the effect of setting different recall rates onradiologist’s performance. Materials and Methods: Institutional ethics approval was granted and informed consentwas obtained from each participating radiologist. Five experienced breast imaging radiologists read a single test setof 200 mammographic cases (20 abnormal and 180 normal). The radiologists were asked to identify each case thatthey required to be recalled in three different recall conditions; free recall, 15% and 10% and mark the location of anysuspicious lesions. Results: Wide variability in recall rates was observed when reading at free recall, ranging from18.5% to 34.0%. Readers demonstrated significantly reduced performance when reading at prescribed recall rates,with lower sensitivity (H=12.891, P=0.002), case location sensitivity (H=12.512, P=0.002) and ROC AUC (H=11.601,P=0.003) albeit with an increased specificity (H=12.704, P=0.002). However, no significant changes were evident inlesion location sensitivity (H=1.982, P=0.371) and JAFROC FOM (H=1.820, P=0.403). Conclusion: In this laboratorystudy, reducing the number of recalled cases to 10% significantly reduced radiologists’ performance with lower detectionsensitivity, although a significant improvement in specificity was observed.