论“不当出生”案件侵害的权利——试分析《侵权责任法》第六条之适用

摘要

The judgments are very different in two cases of ＂wrongful birth＂ which are the same basically. According to the analysis of these two cases, ＂wrongful birth＂ impairs female ＂ reproductive fights＂ which belongs to the ＂personality fights＂, fits the Article 6 of Tort Liability Law. It means medical institutions should be responsible for the compensation.%在两起案件基本相同的“不当出生”案件中，判决结果迥异。经对两案评析认为，“不当出生”案件侵害了产妇的“生育自主权”，该权利为“人格权”，适用《侵权责任法》第六条，医疗机构应承担损害赔偿责任。