李昌奎案终审结果的政法考量——对云南高院改判原因的几点质疑

摘要

李昌奎案凸现了司法机关终审法院对立法宗旨、人权法律应用理解上的错误,以及贯彻国家＂少杀、慎杀＂＂宽严相济＂司法原则认识上的偏差,终审法院改判原因应当从政治理论、法律理论两方面进行认真的辨析。我国还是一个发展中国家,社会经济水平低下,人权的提高和应用应当与社会发展水平相适应,李昌奎案终审结果应当通过审判监督程序的再审或提审予以纠正。%The Li Chang-kui′s case highlights that among the judicial departments and the court of final appeals,there is a misunderstanding of the application of legislative purpose and the human right law and there are errors in judgment on ＂be killed and allowed to kill＂,and ＂in the enforcers＂ in the justice principle.The court of final appeals should consider the amended causes from two aspects of the political theory and the legal theory.Our country is still a developing country with low social and economical level and the improvement and application of human rights should be in accord with the social development.The final result of the case should be judged again or be committed for trial under the procedures of judicial supervision in order to correct the problem.