庄子故里东明说质疑

摘要

According to documents of Pre -Qin period as well as Shui Jing (水经) and Shui Jing Zhu (水经注) , the correct native place of Zhuang Zi should be a place south of Caoxian County in Shandong , north of Shangqiu City and east of Minquan County in He ’ nan.Recently, some scholars think that the native place of Zhuang Zi is in Dongming in Shandong;however , this assumption is untenable , the arguments of which are seem-ingly right but actually wrong .%据先秦文献及《水经》《水经注》记载，庄子故里的准确位置应在今山东曹县以南、河南商丘以北、民权县以东。近年来有的学者提出庄子故里在山东东明，然东明说者所持之论据皆似是而非，是不能成立的。