Horizontal Stress: The Root of all Evil?

摘要

The effects of horizontal stress in coal mine roofs in South Africa did not receive the attention it deserved for several years, but now there is a danger that it may be over emphasized. A number of phenomena that are ascribed to elevated levels of horizontal stress, are shown to be explained by fundamental considerations. The stress concentration caused by the creation of an opening in rock and the beam effects in a stratified roof are briefly reviewed. It is shown that guttering can be present without high horizontal stress, depending on the nature of the roof material. Three examples from practice are presented where horizontal stress was initially erroneously believed to be responsible for roof collapses. A comprehensive program of roof displacement monitoring in South Africa yielded results that are compatible with gravity loading on roof beams without the assistance of horizontal stress. It is also shown that one of the diagrams that are used to explain guttering as a result of horizontal stress is misleading. The over emphasis on horizontal stress may obscure the real causes of roof instability, resulting in ineffective remedial action to be taken by mine operators.