Evaluating Multimodal Systems

摘要

This paper describes the analysis of established and new questionnaires concerning their applicability for the assessment of quality aspects of multimodal systems. To this purpose, an experiment with 27 participants interacting with a a smart-home system via a voice interface, a smartphone-based interface and a multimodal interface, was conducted. Interaction parameters were assessed and related to constructs measured with these questionnaires. The results indicate that some of the questionnaires are suitable for evaluating multimodal interfaces. On the basis of correlations with interaction parameters subscales of these questionnaires can be mapped to quality aspects, such as effectiveness and efficiency. Recommendations are given how to meet two important evaluation requirements, namely which questionnaire to use for comparing two or more systems or system versions and how to identify factors or components in a system that have to be improved. This is another step forward to establish evaluation methods for multimodal systems.