Scientific Discussion: Open Reviews of 'ARTI Reference Architecture - PROSA Revisited'

摘要

This chapter gathers a number of reviews that offer an open, scientific discussion on the transition from PROSA, the well-known reference architecture for Holonic Manufacturing Systems proposed twenty years ago by the School of Leuven, Belgium, to ARTI - the new reference model for IT-based general-purpose control systems proposed by Paul Valckenaers, that stimulates a higher level of abstraction and genericity in understanding and inferring reality. ARTI models architecture elements of reality as intelligent beings in a dominant position relative to their related decision-making components modelled as intelligent agents. The reviews start with overviews of the creation process, the structural elements - holon classes and the features -aggregation, specialization, abstraction levels, flexibility and scalability. The needs that led to the evolution of PROSA into ARTI are analysed: the difficulties to spread the architecture in the research community and industry, the lack of suitability to act as reference architecture for Cyber-Physical Production Systems and Industrial Internet of Things framework in the Industry 4.0 vision of future manufacturing. The reviews discuss the elements and coverage of ARTI, and the translation of basic and staff PROSA holons into new abstract categories: intelligent beings-agents, types-instances, and resources-activities. It is appreciated that, beyond the problem of terminology of PROSA holons difficult to apply in other domains than manufacturing, the move to ARTI assures indepth interoperability, access to the world-of-interest through digital twins that interact with smart control systems influencing thus these intelligent beings (e.g., plant, shop floor, healthcare system, environment facility, supply chain, service system) into the desired behaviours. From the software implementing point of view, most of the reviewers agreed on the fact that none of the programming languages except for Erlang provided acceptable levels of viabili