Ground Reaction Force Comparison of Bilateral Symmetry with Pneumatic Resistance Squat Device and Free Weights

摘要

INTRODUCTION: The unloading of spaceflight leads to bone and muscle atrophy, and a pneumatic resistance squat exercise countermeasure has the potential to provide optimized controllable resistance in a lightweight and compact configuration. However each end of the barbell in the proposed device is connected to a separate resistance cylinder which could lead to bilaterally asymmetric loading. Therefore, the purpose of the study is to compare the unilateral ground reaction forces (GRF) of the new squat device compared to free weights. METHODS: Four previously trained men (mean ± SD; age = 20±2 years, body mass = 99±18 kg) performed three sets of three repetitions of maximal exertion squat exercises with pneumatically controlled constant resistance and free weights each with a resistance level set to half of the body weight of each subject. Unilateral GRF data for each lifting modality at the negative to positive transition of the squat exercise was measured with a force plate under each foot. RESULTS: The pneumatic resistance GRF (N; mean ± SD) was 749±114 on the left leg and 786±123 on the right leg and the free weight GRF was 786±114 left and 861±111 right resulting in a 5% difference between left and right GRF with pneumatics and 9% difference with free weights. The correlation coefficient between left and right GRF was 0.92 with pneumatics and 0.80 with free weights. CONCLUSION: Because the pneumatic device elicited more bilaterally symmetric GRF than traditional free weights, the separate resistance cylinders are an acceptable design configuration.