Transformation of professional identity: an exploration of psychologists and psychiatrists implementing Open Dialogue

摘要

This study explored how psychologists and psychiatrists working in Australian youth mental health services constructed their professional identity, and whether and how implementing Open Dialogue transformed this. Nine clinicians (psychologists, clinical psychologists and psychiatrists) were interviewed after completing Open Dialogue training. Interviews were subjected to discourse analysis. First, two general pre-existing discursive professional identity positions were constructed: (i) psychiatrists rhetorically distancing themselves from the medical model as 'fixers' of mental illness; and (ii) psychologists and psychiatrists rhetorically embracing their personal identity. Second, participants' responses about implementing Open Dialogue revealed opportunities and discomforts, including: (i) dialogical approaches offering psychiatrists an alternative identity to 'fixers'; and (ii) dialogical approaches generating discomfort at the risk of exposing participants' own vulnerability. Participants' professional identities comprised contrasting positions. Practitioner points