What is the best method for calculating the optimal position of an esophageal pH probe in children?

摘要

In assessment of distal esophageal pH, the sensor of the probe should be placed above the upper border of the lower esophageal sphincter. There are several methods to estimate the distance from the nose where the probe should be fixed according to the patient's height. We studied the accuracy of these methods. Data of patients who underwent esophageal monitoring were collected prospectively. The esophageal pH electrode was set with the aid of fluoroscopy in all cases, considering the location recommended by the current guideline. Esophageal probe position and anthropometric data of each patient were recorded. We compared the actual esophageal pH electrode distance from the nose with that estimated by Nowak's, Strobel's, Staiano-Clouse's, and Moreau's formulae and the Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) table. A total of 98 patients were included, with ages ranging from 2 months to 19 years old. The highest success rate (67%) for all age groups was achieved by Nowak's formula (3.2 + 0.2 x height in cm). Considering only children under 3 years old, the GOSH table reached the highest—yet probably overestimated—fraction of adequate predictions. A corrected Staiano and Clouse's formula (4.28 + 0.191 x height in cm) had a slightly lower success rate than Nowak's due to a poorer performance in younger children. In conclusion, Nowak's formula is the most accurate regardless of age. It can help reduce radiation due to systematic fluoroscopy, as well as the subsequent manipulation of the esophageal probe. However, it still leads to pH sensor misplacements in more than one-third of children. In consequence, a confirmatory X-ray is advisable even after using the formula.