Nussbaum's capability approach and African environmental ethics: is the African voice heard?

摘要

Martha Nussbaum's capability approach (CA) offers a framework for a universal conception of human development. This paper interrogates Nussbaum's approach using African environmental ethics (AEE) to see if it captures African ways of valuing nature. It looks at two ways in which Nussbaum's approach considers the value of the natural environment: a) by applying her list of capabilities to non-human animals and b) by including, what is here termed, an environmental capability in Nussbaum's list of tencentral capabilities she deems necessary for a person to flourish. The author argues that, despite limitations and need for further exploration, the second way of 'environment capability' aligns well with how nature is valued in AEE. The author also shows that both Nussbaum and AEE value nature in a way that, while not necessarily intrinsic, goes beyond material instrumentality and opens avenues for further discussion of the capabilities approach in traditional value systems.