Flexible transnasal endoscopy with white light or narrow band imaging for the diagnosis of laryngeal malignancy: diagnostic value, observer variability and influence of previous laryngeal surgery

摘要

PurposeFlexible transnasal endoscopy is a common examination technique for the evaluation of laryngeal lesions, while the use of narrow band imaging (NBI) has been reported to enhance the diagnostic value of white light endoscopy (WLE). The purpose of this study is to assess observer variability and diagnostic value of both modalities and investigate the possible influence of previous laryngeal surgery on the detection rates of laryngeal malignancy.MethodsThe study was based on the retrospective evaluation of 170 WLE and NBI images of laryngeal lesions by three observers in a random order. The histopathological diagnoses serve as the gold standard.ResultsIn identifying laryngeal malignancy, the sensitivity of NBI proved to be higher than that of WLE (93.3% vs. 77.0%). NBI was also superior to WLE in terms of accuracy (96.3% vs. 92%) and diagnostic odds ratio (501.83 vs. 120.65). Both modalities had a specificity of 97.3%. The inter-observer agreement was substantial (kappa=0.661) for WLE and almost perfect (kappa=0.849) for NBI. Both WLE and NBI showed a high level of intra-observer agreement. The sensitivity was significantly lower in images with history of previous laryngeal surgery compared to those without.ConclusionsFlexible transnasal endoscopy has been proved to be a valuable tool in the diagnosis of laryngeal malignancy. The use of NBI can increase the sensitivity and observer reliability in that context and can also provide a diagnostic gain in cases with previous laryngeal surgery