The Critical Shoulder Angle Shows a Reciprocal Change in Magnitude When Evaluating Symptomatic Full-Thickness Rotator Cuff Tears Versus Primary Glenohumeral Osteoarthritis as Compared With Control Subjects: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

摘要

Purpose: To determine whether a high critical shoulder angle (CSA) is associated with symptomatic full-thickness rotator cuff (RC) tears and/or whether a low C SA is associated with primary glenohumeral osteoarthritis (GHOA). Methods: A systematic review was performed following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. All observational studies that examined an association between CSA and full-thickness RC tears and/or primary GHOA were included. A primary meta-analysis was performed including all studies that met the inclusion criteria regardless of radiographic quality. A secondary meta-analysis was performed to explore the hypothesis that radiographic quality was a source of heterogeneity, which excluded those studies in which radiograph quality was not strictly defined and controlled. Results: For the primary meta-analysis, 11 studies met the inclusion criteria for RC tears and 5 for primary GHOA. The C SA was greater in the RC tear group than the control group (mean difference 4.03 degrees, 95% confidence interval 2.95 degrees-5.11, 95% prediction interval 0.0487 degrees-8.01 degrees; P < .001). The C SA was lower in the GHOA group than the control group (mean difference -3.98 degrees, 95% confidence interval -5.66 degrees to -2.31 degrees, 95% prediction interval -10.2 degrees to -2.19 degrees; P < .001).A high level of heterogeneity was observed in the RC tear analysis (I-2 = 88.4), which decreased after the exclusion of 5 studies based on radiographic quality (I-2 = 75.3). A high level of heterogeneity also was observed in the primary GHOA analysis (I-2 = 87.3), which decreased after the exclusion of 2 studies based on the radiographic quality (I-2 = 48.2). Conclusions: There is a reciprocal change in magnitude of the C SA when evaluating symptomatic full-thickness RC tears versus primary GHOA as compared with control subjects. Radiographic quality is a source of heterogeneity in studies that investigate a link between C SA and RC tears and primary GHOA.