Profile-Guided Static Typing for Dynamic Scripting Languages

摘要

Many popular scripting languages such as Ruby, Python, and Perl include highly dynamic language constructs, such as an e v a l method that evaluates a string as program text. While these constructs allow terse and expressive code, they have traditionally obstructed static analysis. In this paper we present P Ruby, an extension to Diamondback Ruby (DRuby), a static type inference system for Ruby. P Ruby augments DRuby with a novel dynamic analysis and transformation that allows us to precisely type uses of highly dynamic constructs. P Ruby's analysis proceeds in three steps. First, we use run-time instrumentation to gather per-application profiles of dynamic feature usage. Next, we replace dynamic features with statically analyzable alternatives based on the profile. We also add instrumentation to safely handle cases when subsequent runs do not match the profile. Finally, we run DRuby's static type inference on the transformed code to enforce type safety. We used P Ruby to gather profiles for a benchmark suite of sample Ruby programs. We found that dynamic features are pervasive throughout the benchmarks and the libraries they include, but that most uses of these features are highly constrained and hence can be effectively profiled. Using the profiles to guide type inference, we found that DRuby can generally statically type our benchmarks modulo some refactoring, and we discovered several previously unknown type errors. These results suggest that profiling and transformation is a lightweight but highly effective approach to bring static typing to highly dynamic languages.