Re-assessing the degradation of benthos beneficial use impairment in the Toronto and Region Area of Concern

摘要

Sediment quality of the Toronto and Region Area of Concern (AOC) waterfront was assessed using a weight of evidence approach following the Sediment Quality Triad, with the addition of contaminant bioaccumulation data, to determine current status following the 2013 re-designation of the ?degradation of benthos? Beneficial Use Impairment as ?no longer impaired.? Five stations within the AOC were sampled in 2015 and compared to lower Great Lakes nearshore reference areas (n = 22) selected based on similarity of sediment physicochemical properties. Sediment chemistry was comparable except for a localized instance of elevated perfluorinated compounds at one AOC site. Laboratory sediment toxicity bioassays indicated chronic toxicity associated with point sources to the AOC, corresponding to increased invertebrate body burdens measured in laboratory exposures. Diversity metrics and multivariate analysis showed that benthic invertebrate community composition present at the AOC sites was not significantly different from reference conditions of the lower Great Lakes. The weight of evidence from this study indicates benthic invertebrate communities continue to show effects of degraded sediment conditions at sites impacted by point sources. While the 2013 RAP decision was to re-designate the ?degradation of benthos? BUI to ?no longer impaired,? our results support the notion that life after AOC delisting must continue to prioritize monitoring efforts. ? 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of International Association for Great Lakes Research. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/Sediment quality of the Toronto and Region Area of Concern (AOC) waterfront was assessed using a weight of evidence approach following the Sediment Quality Triad, with the addition of contaminant bioaccumulation data, to determine current status following the 2013 re-designation of the ?degradation of benthos? Beneficial Use Impairment as ?no longer impaired.? Five stations within the AOC were sam-pled in 2015 and compared to lower Great Lakes nearshore reference areas (n = 22) selected based on similarity of sediment physicochemical properties. Sediment chemistry was comparable except for a localized instance of elevated perfluorinated compounds at one AOC site. Laboratory sediment toxicity bioassays indicated chronic toxicity associated with point sources to the AOC, corresponding to increased invertebrate body burdens measured in laboratory exposures. Diversity metrics and multivariate analysis showed that benthic invertebrate community composition present at the AOC sites was not significantly different from reference conditions of the lower Great Lakes. The weight of evidence from this study indi-cates benthic invertebrate communities continue to show effects of degraded sediment conditions at sites impacted by point sources. While the 2013 RAP decision was to re-designate the ?degradation of benthos? BUI to ?no longer impaired,? our results support the notion that life after AOC delisting must continue to prioritize monitoring efforts. ? 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of International Association for Great Lakes Research. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).