Estimation of relative economic weights and the marginal willingness to pay for breeding traits of Brown Swiss cattle using discrete choice experiments

摘要

Breeding traits are usually combined in a total merit index according to their economic weights to maximize genetic gain based on economic merit. However, this maximization may not always be the aim of the selection decisions by farm managers. A discrete choice experiment was used to evaluate the importance of traits in terms of the selection decisions of farm managers operating in different environments. Six trait complexes, the semen price, the interactions between these traits, and significant characteristics of the farms were included in a conditional logit model to estimate relative economic weights and the marginal willingness to pay for all traits. Milk value, conformation/udder, and fitness were the most important traits for the farmers, and significant interactions indicated that fitness is of greater importance on organically managed farms than on conventional farms. Farm managers with an advanced education placed more weight on the milk value trait than farm managers without advanced education. On conventional farms, managers weighted the traits milk value and conformation/udder highly. The conformation/udder and fitness trait complexes were important on organic farms. A new trait called perinatal sucking behavior of newborn calves should be included in the total merit index.