Total thyroidectomy: Conventional Suture Ligation technique versus sutureless techniques using Harmonic Scalpel or Maxium

摘要

Objectives Harmonic Scalpel (HS) and Maxium (MAX) are surgical shears that enable simultaneous vessel sealing and tissue coagulation. This study compares the outcome of Total Thyroidectomy (TT) using Conventional Suture Ligation (CSL) technique versus (vs) two sutureless techniques; H S and MAX techniques in terms of safety, operative time, blood drainage volume, hospital stay and surgical complications. Study design This is a prospective observational cohort study. Setting This study was performed in AL-Karama Teaching Hospital/College of Medicine/University of Wasit/Iraq. Patients and methods This study was performed from June 2012 to 2015. A total of 80 patients, 60 patients were females and 20 patients were males (average/mean of age was 39/38 years). They underwent TT after been randomized into the following three groups: CSL group when Suture Ligation Technique was used, HS group when Harmonic Scalpel was used and MAX group when bipolar electrosurgery Maxium was used. Results The postoperative evaluation of operative time, blood drainage volume and surgical complications revealed no statistically significant differences between HS group & MAX group, but there were statistically significant differences between CSL group vs. HS and MAX groups. Operative time statistics showed significant differences between CSL vs. HS and MAX groups, 113?±?10.9?minutes (min), 93?±?13?min and 92?±?10.6?min respectively, p-value<0.001 and 95% confidence interval [CI] (92.3712, 101.6288). The postoperative blood drainage volumes were significantly different between the three groups: CSL group?=?150?±?12.7?ml, HS group?=?89?±?16.21?ml and MAX group?=?118?±?9.6?ml, P-value?=?0.046 and 95% [CI] (89.9932, 99.6068). Conclusions HS and MAX are safe, effective, and time-saving techniques. They are also associated with low blood loss and low complication rates. HS and MAX are good alternative techniques to CSL for thyroid surgery. Highlights ? HS and MAX are safe useful and fast alternatives to conventional techniques in total thyroidectomy. ? These two devices facilitate surgical procedures and cancel any need for clips and suture ligations. ? They significantly reduce operative time without increases in the amount of blood losses and hospital stay. ? Probably the only disadvantage of these two devices is the cost of the single-use devices.