Accuracy and privacy aspects in free online reverse geocoding services

摘要

Reverse geocoding is defined as the extraction of textual information, such as a name or an address, from geographic coordinates. This technique is common in many geo-application scenarios, e.g., in freely available online-based mapping services. However, if personal data are mapped, confidentiality issues may arise, such as if the data are derived from a crime-incidents database. This research provides an evaluation of seven freely available Web mapping services in regard to reverse geocoding accuracy and privacy aspects. The services' textual accuracy is measured using crime data from Vienna, Austria. The accuracy associated with reverse geocoding is derived for districts with different residential densities to determine whether any error variation is associated with the underlying residential structure. Furthermore, this research investigates the reidentification risk when compromising personal information. Using a free online telephone database and addresses in a crime-incidents dataset, the probable names that are linked to crime victims are identified. The results showed that the accuracy ranges from 0% to 23% depending on the predefined precision level. Comparing seven online reverse geocoding services (TravelGIS, Google Maps, nominatim, ArcGIS, Yahoo, Bing, and Geonames), TravelGIS performs better at the highest precision level, whereas Geonames performs better at a lower precision level. However, the results showed no difference among the districts with different residential densities. As for the reidentification risk, 68% probable victims were identified from the database. This work discusses the specific tasks that users have to complete when retrieving addresses associated with crime-incident locations. The article concludes with an evaluation of the reverse geocoding process and a discussion of the privacy risk associated with it.