Gintis Meets Brunswik - But Fails To Recognize Him

摘要

With a few incisive (and legitimate) criticisms of crucial experiments in psychology that purported to bring down the foundations of modern economics, together with a broad scholarly review that is praiseworthy, Gintis attempts to build a unifying framework for the behavioral sciences. His efforts fail, however, because he fails to break with the conventional methodology, which, regrettably, is the unifying basis of the behavioral sciences. As a result, his efforts will merely recapitulate the story of the past: interesting, provocative results that are soon overthrown because they are limited to the conditions of the experiment. Gintis is keenly aware of this limitation - and thus meets Brunswik, but fails to recognize him; this we know because he seems unaware of the fact that Brunswik said it all - and provided a detailed defense - a half century ago.