Implementing Group Medical Visits for Older Adults at Group Health Cooperative

摘要

In a pair of randomized controlled trials in Kaiser Colorado in the 1990s, Group Visits for older adults (monthly non disease-specific group medical appointments for a cohort of patients led by primary care teams) were proven to reduce costs, decrease hospitalizations, and improve patient and provider satisfaction. As part of a translational effort, this Group Visit intervention was replicated in a delivery system in Seattle, WA, and the log of total health care costs measured in the first year of the intervention. Utilization and patient and physician satisfaction were secondary outcomes. For the cost and utilization analysis, a retrospective case-control design compared 221 case patients 65 years of age and older with high outpatient utilization in the previous 18 months with 1,015 control patient selected randomly from clinics not participating in the intervention. Controls were matched to cases on the number of primary care visits in the prior 18 months. Total costs were not statistically different for intervention patients compared to controls ($8,845 vs. $10,288, p=0.11), nor were there statistically significant differences in utilization, including hospital admissions and outpatient visits. However, patient and provider satisfaction was high. This translational effort did not demonstrate the cost savings of the original efficacy trials. Possible explanations for these divergent results may have to do with differences in those who participated and differences between the two delivery systems.