Discrete Element Analysis is a Valid Method for Computing JointContact Stress in the Hip before and after Acetabular Fracture

摘要

Evaluation of abnormalities in joint contact stress that develop after inaccurate reduction of an acetabular fracture may provide a potential means for predicting the risk of developing post-traumatic osteoarthritis. Discrete element analysis (DEA) is a computational technique for calculating intra-articular contact stress distributions in a fraction of the time required to obtain the same information using the more commonly employed finite element analysis technique. The goal of this work was to validate the accuracy of DEA-computed contact stress against physical measurements of contact stress made in cadaveric hips using Tekscan sensors. Four static loading tests in a variety of poses from heel-strike to toe-off were performed in two different cadaveric hip specimens with the acetabulum intact and again with an intentionally malreduced posterior wall acetabular fracture. DEA-computed contact stress was compared on a point-by-point basis to stress measured from the physical experiments. There was good agreement between computed and measured contact stress over the entire contact area (correlation coefficients ranged from 0.88-0.99). DEA-computed peak contact stress was within an average of 0.5 MPa (range 0.2 MPa - 0.8 MPa) of the Tekscan peak stress for intact hips, and withinan average of 0.6 MPa (range 0 – 1.6 MPa) for fractured cases.DEA-computed contact areas were within an average of 33% of theTekscan-measured areas (range: 1.4% - 60%). These resultsindicate that the DEA methodology is a valid method for accurately estimatingcontact stress in both intact and fractured hips.