从柳词论案看矛盾词学观

摘要

It was one of the most controversial case about Liu ci comment in the history of ci. The controversial comment on Liu ci＇s double cultural characters - elegant or custom, had been extended to the late Qing Dynasty. The reason of Liu ci＇s case was not only the history put forward constructing cultural character on ci, but also relating to the inherent contradiction of ci values as literati ci appeared in the early days.%关于柳词的评论，是词学史上争议最多的案例之一。由宋代形成的对柳词“雅”、“俗”二重文化品格的矛盾性评价，一直延伸至清末。柳词论案的造成不仅是由于历史提出建立曲子词的文化品格的要求，也与文人词出现之初即存在词学价值观的内在矛盾有关。