医疗事故罪20年理论争鸣的司法实证回应

摘要

自1997年～2017年,"医疗事故罪"的设立已经走过整整20年.医疗事故罪的罪状简短,却引发众多学者孜孜不倦地求索一个合理的解释,从立法到司法,从刑事到民事,有关医疗事故罪的理论争鸣方兴未艾.为此,文章结合20年的司法案例进行实证分析,并对理论争鸣中的一些观点予以回应,从而提出医疗事故罪未来立法与司法的合理建议.%The past two decades have witnessed the judgment of crime of medical accident in China since it was added in the Criminal Law of China in 1997. Despite its short facts, the crime of medical accidents remains controversial in the aspects from legislation to judicature and from criminal to civil suit. Based on our empirical analysis of judicial cases in the past 20 years, we responded to some competing viewpoints and proposed suggestions on future legislation and judicial practice of the crime of medical accidents.