Design and Evaluation of a Corridors-in-the-sky Concept: The Benefits and Feasibility of Adding Highly Structured Routes to a Mixed Equipage Environment

摘要

A human-in-the-loop simulation of a Corridors-in-the-sky concept was conducted that focused on investigating the potential benefits and feasibility of the concept with human operators in a realistic environment. In this simulation, the definition of "corridors" was changed from meaning separate corridor airspace with dedicated corridor controllers to highly structured routes with potentially common speeds and avionics equipage. The change in definition allowed the concept to be realizable within the mid-term Next Generation Air Transportation System (NextGen) timeframe and mitigated many of the feasibility issues that were identified in earlier research. Feasibility and benefits were tested through the variance of traffic levels within the test airspace (High and Max). In the High Traffic condition, the radar (R-side) and supporting data (D-side) controllers managed a high level of traffic without aircraft being rerouted out of the congested sectors. In the Max Traffic condition, a traffic flow manager and area supervisors worked together to reroute aircraft out of the congested sectors. Four different procedures were tested with different corridor structures: (1) no specific corridors (No Corridors), (2) only equipped aircraft within corridors (Equipped in Corridors), (3) only unequipped aircraft within corridors (Unequipped in Corridors), and (4) a mix of both equipped and unequipped aircraft within corridors (Mixed in Corridors). Surrounding non-corridor traffic consisted of a 50/50 mix of Data Comm and non-Data Comm equipped aircraft in all conditions. The results of the study indicate that the Equipped in Corridors condition showed the greatest benefits with the highest levels of throughput and the lowest reported workload relative to the other conditions. In contrast, the Unequipped in Corridors condition showed little throughput or workload benefits relative to the No Corridors condition. The results for the Mixed in Corridors condition fell in between the values observed for Equipped in Corridors and No Corridors. Feedback from the participants revealed that the observed reduction in benefits when unequipped aircraft were in the corridors was a result of the workload associated with the communications and monitoring required for the unequipped corridor aircraft as well as the display clutter of their data blocks. In addition, the study showed that the concept was feasible and was well received by the participants. Service for equipage was also shown to be feasible with fewer Data Comm equipped aircraft rerouted than non-Data Comm equipped aircraft.