Report of the Peer Review Dialog Meeting 2009-07-28

摘要

The meeting was held in an atmosphere of optimism; in general, the participating authors felt that the reviews they have received are helpful and not overly "hostile". We learned that reviewers are evaluated by thread chairs from this year on. Insofar as this assessment information is fed back to reviewers, it may be useful for the latter and contribute to improvement of review.There were a number of suggestions that attendees brought up which will be elaborated in the following. The nature of the topics suggest that we rename our "Peer Review Meeting" to "Conference Review Meeting". This reflects the purpose of the meeting more accurately.