Accuracy and repeatability of parameter estimation methods from ambulatory data for the wrist joint

摘要

In this paper, as a preliminary study, we show that accuracy and repeatability in ambulatory measurements of wrist joint are related to movement conditions which are going to be used in a calibration procedure. We chose two representative in-vivo, non-invasive calibration methods of the human upper limb, from those available in literature, to estimate joint parameters. Developing an analytical model of wrist joint we used sets of synthetic data each of which containing different number of samples, joint covariations and noise to estimate the repeatability and accuracy of the methods in estimation. Afterwards, we used our mechanical mock-up to examine single joint motions as well as the rotation of both joints (i.e. flexion-extension rotation and radial-ulnar deviation) on accuracy and repeatability by calculating the mean and standard deviation of the relative errors. Finally, we show that the accuracy of adapted method (its relative error was less than 7%) is better than the other method in estimating the joint parameters.