Analyzing the Effect of Different Partial Overlap Sizes in Perceiving Visual Variables

摘要

Element overlap in visualization techniques is a known problem, and high amounts of data and lack of available visual space potentialize this issue. Many studies have applied techniques to reduce occlusion levels in data visualizations, such as random jitter, element transparency, layout rearrangement, and focus+context techniques. However, few studies focus on the presence of occlusion, which is a relevant topic for visualizations where some degree of overlap is inevitable or purposefully explored. This paper takes a step in this direction, and presents a comparative study of visual variables, measuring their robustness to overlap and number of unique values. The study used a grid layout to display visual variables (hue, saturation, shape, text, orientation, and texture), and varied percentage of occlusion (0%, 50%, 60%, and 70%) and number of unique values (3, 4, and 5) to measure the effect they cause on the speed and accuracy to locate the visual variables. Hence, 48 volunteers performed locate tasks on a tool that automatically generate a grid of visual variables and collect their answers. The results revealed that hue and shape were robust to high occlusion levels and a high number of unique values. Text and texture had medium loss of performance, while saturation and orientation were the most negatively affected.