Dyspnea in Children with Life-Threatening and Life-Limiting Complex Chronic Conditions

摘要

Background: Dyspnea is one of the most frequent symptoms in children with complex chronic conditions (CCC) requiring palliative care. Although it is a subject of high importance, there has been little research on dyspnea in critically ill children. Objective: The purpose of this systematic review was to investigate the prevalence and causes of dyspnea in children with CCC and to identify the current state of research on the measurements, treatments, and the evaluation of therapeutic interventions. Methods: A systematic literature search for relevant literature from 1990 until the present was performed using the online database PubMed. Information about prevalence, pathophysiological mechanisms, measurement, and treatment of dyspnea was extracted from all 43 eligible publications. Results: The prevalence ranged widely from 17 to 80. Breathlessness was primarily attributed to a disease-specific pathophysiology. A multidimensional approach has not been reported. Assessment of dyspnea included eight tools using either subjective self- or proxy-ratings or objective measures. Evidence for the effectiveness of various treatment approaches was low. Discussion: The prevalence rates for dyspnea could be generalized across all conditions and patient subgroups. The biopsychosocial-spiritual approach was not addressed by the studies. There is a lack of an adequate and validated measurement tool that can be applied to children of various ages and diagnoses, communication ability, and practicable across different settings. Most found treatment approaches lacked good evidence in children. Conclusion: Although the prevalence rate of dyspnea in pediatric palliative care is high, it has been poorly studied.