Comparison of environment quality measurements between 3 types of calf housing in the United Kingdom

摘要

Preweaning calves are kept in a range of hous-ing types that offer variable protection against the weather and provide differing internal environments. This cross-sectional observational study assessed the effect of housing type (shed, polytunnel, or hutches) on internal environmental parameters, using 2 blocks of 8-wk measurements from 10 commercial dairy farms in the south of England, covering both summer and winter periods. Continuous measurements for internal and external temperature and humidity were recorded by data logger placed within the calf housing and used to calculate the temperature-humidity index (THI). Weekly point readings were also taken for tempera-ture, humidity, light, air speed, ammonia level, and airborne particulate matter. Airborne bacterial levels were determined at wk 2, 5, and 8 by incubating air samples at 35 degrees C for 24 h in aerobic conditions. Data were analyzed using linear mixed models. Housing type influenced THI significantly in both seasons. In sum-mer, calves were exposed to heat stress conditions (THI >= 72) for 39, 31, and 14 of 46 d in polytunnel hous-ing, hutches, and sheds, respectively. The maximum summer temperature (37.0 degrees C) was recorded in both hutch and polytunnel housing, with sheds remaining consistently cooler (maximum 31.0 degrees C). In winter, the lowest minimum internal temperature recorded was in hutches at -4.5 degrees C, with both the sheds and polytun-nel, but not hutches, providing a significant increase in temperature compared with the external environment. Hutches remained <= 10 degrees C for 86% of the winter study period. Light levels were reduced in all housing types compared with the external environment. The particu-late matter in air that is capable of reaching the lungs (particulate matter <10 mu m) was highest in sheds, intermediate in hutches, and lowest in polytunnel hous-ing (0.97 +/- 3.75, 0.37 +/- 0.44, and 0.20 +/- 0.24 mg/m3, respectively). This was mirrored by airborne bacterial numbers, which were also highest in sheds (8,017 +/- 2,141 cfu/m3), intermediate in hutches (6,870 +/- 2,084 cfu/m3), and lowest in the polytunnel (3,357 +/- 2,572 cfu/m3). Round, white, catalase-positive, and oxidase-negative colonies were most prevalent, likely indicating Staphylococcus species. This study demonstrated that UK calves are routinely exposed to either heat or cold stress, especially when housed in hutches or polytun-nels. Sheds had the highest levels of particulate matter and airborne bacteria, both known contributory fac-tors for respiratory disease. These findings demonstrate that all calf housing systems result in environmental compromises that could have long-term impacts on calf health and growth; therefore, further studies should identify husbandry and housing modifications to miti-gate these factors.