On the self-consistency of DFT-1/2

摘要

Density functional theory (DFT)-1/2 is an efficient bandgap rectification method for DFT under local density approximation (LDA) or gener-alized gradient approximation. It was suggested that non-self-consistent DFT-1/2 should be used for highly ionic insulators like LiF, whereas self-consistent DFT-1/2 should still be used for other compounds. Nevertheless, there is no quantitative criterion prescribed for which imple-mentation should work for an arbitrary insulator, which leads to severe ambiguity in this method. In this work, we analyze the impact of self-consistency in DFT-1/2 and shell DFT-1/2 calculations in insulators or semiconductors with ionic bonds, covalent bonds, and inter-mediate cases and show that self-consistency is required even for highly ionic insulators for globally better electronic structure details. The self-energy correction renders electrons more localized around the anions in self-consistent LDA-1/2. The well-known delocalization error of LDA is rectified, but with strong overcorrection, due to the presence of additional self-energy potential. However, in non-self-consistent LDA-1/2 calculations, the electron wave functions indicate that such localization is much more severe and beyond a reasonable range because the strong Coulomb repulsion is not counted in the Hamiltonian. Another common drawback of non-self-consistent LDA-1/2 is that the ionicity of the bonding gets substantially enhanced, and the bandgap can be enormously high in mixed ionic-covalent compounds like TiO2.